A San Diego Tradition Since 1991

Experience authentic Mexican flavors and warm hospitality in the heart of Bankers Hill. Famous for our Tlaquepaque sauce and all-day breakfast.

View Our Menu
Jimmy Carter's Mexican Cafe Interior

Taste the Tradition

Legendary Sauces

Our famous Tlaquepaque sauce—a creamy blend of roasted jalapeños and cilantro—is a local obsession.

Handcrafted Margaritas

From our Crisp Cucumber to the Spicy Serrano, our margaritas are made with fresh juices and premium tequilas.

All-Day Breakfast

Enjoy Huevos Rancheros, Nuevo Leon Enchiladas, and classic American favorites any time of day.

Loved by Locals

“This is our favorite place in town. The Tlaquepaque sauce on ANYTHING is amazing. Definitely go check it out!”

L

Lindsey L.

2 months ago · via Y

“I've eaten here many times over the years and have never had a bad meal. The shrimp taco salad and shredded chicken quesadilla were delicious.”

S

Stephanie Benttinen

a month ago · via G

“Without a doubt my 2nd favorite place to eat in San Diego. Authentic Mexican food with welcoming employees who treat you like family.”

A

Abby R.

3 months ago · via Y

Come Say Hola

Located in the beautiful Bankers Hill neighborhood, just minutes from Balboa Park. We have a pet-friendly patio!

3172 Fifth Ave San Diego, CA 92103

Get Directions

Jimmy Carter's Mexican Cafe

Authentic flavors and neighborhood vibes in Bankers Hill since 1991.

Visit Us

3172 Fifth Ave San Diego, CA 92103

(619) 295-2070

f IG ?